UNBC students, prof at leading edge of human rights lawsuit

A landmark lawsuit launched by 11 Guatemalan women against Canadian mining company HudBay Minerals and its subsidiaries alleging rape, beatings and forced evictions has a UNBC connection.

On Monday Toronto lawyer Murray Klippenstein filed a lawsuit in Ontario court seeking $55 million in damages on behalf of 11 women of the Mayan Q'eqchi community of Lote Ocho.

article continues below

"On Jan. 17, 2007, at the request of Canadian mining company HMI Nickel Inc., hundreds of mine security personnel, police and military forcibly expelled members of the remote indigenous Mayan community of Lote Ocho from land that community members consider to be their ancestral home in eastern Guatemala," the statement of claim says. "During these armed evictions, 11 Mayan Q'eqchi' women were gang-raped by police, military and mine security personnel. The mine security personnel who committed the rapes were deployed at HMI Nickel's Fenix mining project, and were under the control and direction of HMI Nickel."

All of these allegations have yet to be proven in court.

UNBC geography professor Catherine Nolin and eight students from Prince George traveled to Guatemala in May, 2010 for a geography field study. On May 19, 2010 Nolin and her students met with women in Lote Ocho and conducted a series of interviews in which the women told them about the alleged rapes.

In a presentation at UNBC on Feb 24, the students spoke about their experience meeting the women.

"Each family was offered 300 quetzals, about $40 Canadian, to leave," student Miranda Seymour said. "They were sprayed with tear gas and rubber bullets."

Student Claudette Bois said they were told 65 houses were, "chainsawed to the ground and burned."

The men had left the village, believing the security and police would not attack unarmed women, Bois said.

According to the statement of claim filed in Ontario Rosa Elbira Coc Ich was sexually assaulted by nine men, including several uniformed Fenix security personnel.

"At first, a police officer drew a pistol and put it to her head and asked her where her husband was. When she was unable to tell him, he said he was going to kill her," the statement alleges. "Because of injuries sustained from the gang rape, Ms. Coc

is no longer able to have children."

Margarita Caal Caal was six months pregnant when she was raped by 10 police, military and uniformed Fenix security personnel, according to the statement of claim.

"Three months later, Ms. Caal gave birth to a baby who was stillborn, possibly due to complications arising from the physical violence of the rape," according the statement of claim.

Bois said the women told them about their experiences so the UNBC students could take it back to Canada.

"This information was not shared by the women of the community... with anyone outside of the community, or even people in the community," Bois said. "They said, 'We demand you tell your leaders to take this company out of here.' The women wanted us to use their images and their words to tell their story. There is no protection, and they know that."

On May 25, 2010 the UNBC group presented their findings to the Canadian Embassy in Guatemala.

"We left that meeting with so little we wanted to scream," Nolin said.

And on July 5, 2010 they submitted a human rights complaint to the office of Canadian Minister of Foreign Affairs Lawrence Cannon.

In an e-mailed response, a Foreign Affairs Canada spokesperson said the government "encourages and expects," Canadian companies working abroad to follow local and and international laws.

"The Government of Guatemala, as a sovereign government, has the responsibility to establish and enforce domestic law in its territory and to ensure that human rights are respected," the spokesperson wrote. "Canada continues to encourage the Guatemalan government to ensure a climate of respect for human rights and security for all its citizens. Canada continues to underscore with Guatemalan officials the importance of investigating allegations of human rights violations and pursuing them fully through the justice system."

Lawyer Murray Klippenstein said companies like HudBay have taken advantage of the dysfunctional legal systems in countries like Guatemala, while Canadian law, "turns a blind eye," to the abuses.

"There is no direct precedent [for the lawsuit], but there has already been a few cases regarding Canadian companies abroad. It is simply a case where the company and the subsidiary have caused harm in a way that would never be accepted in Canada," Klippenstein said.

The violence started on Jan. 8, 2007 according to the statement of claim. CGN security, police and military arrived at Lote Ocho in trucks to evict the residents -which in a press release HudBay calls "illegal squatters."

Dozens of houses were burned, goods stolen from residents and guns fired, the statement of claim says. Residents returned the next day to try and rebuild their homes and salvage their crops, it added.

Guatemalan environmentalist and human rights advocate Magali Rey Rosa said the case of Lote Ocho is all-too typical in the country.

Rey Rosa said the response by Foreign Affairs Canada, "makes me want to cry."

"First off, Guatemala is an extremely racist country where the indigenous people have been purposely excluded," Rey Rosa said. "Our justice system does not work. Our institutions are weak."

Community-organized referendums called, "consultas," have been held in communities throughout Guatemala, she said. In those consultas communities have voiced overwhelming opposition to mining and hydroelectric projects in the country, she said.

In a February, 2007 report to the United Nations Philip Aiston - special reporter on extrajudicial, summary or arbitrary executions - found only 1.4 per cent of murders in the country in 2005 resulted in a conviction.

A second UN report in February, 2009 cited "a general climate of impunity" in the country

and that only four per cent of crimes ended up before the courts.

In 2005 the International Commission of Jurists reported, "The independence and

impartiality of the judiciary is severely threatened by the an increasing politicizing of the justice system," in Guatemala.

Judges and prosecutors in the country are subjected to political interference, threats and intimidation, the report added.

In January, 2011 Human Rights Watch reported that impunity, lack of accountability for human rights violations

Wealthy multinational companies can buy a lot of government cooperation in Guatemala, Rey Rosa said.

"Our politicians are cheap," she said. "It is not really the government, it's the government officials that see their futures in operating the mining company."

Klippenstein's firm is working pro bono on the case, but is accepting donations toward the cost of the case. The firm is also bringing a second lawsuit against HudBay on behalf of the widow of a Adolfo Ich Chaman - a Mayan Q'eqchi' opposed to the Fenix Nickel Project. In that statement of claim, Angelica Choc claims her husband was shot to death on Sept. 27, 2009 during a protest against the mining project.

In the statement of claim, witnesses identified Mynor Padilla - the head of security at Fenix - as the shooter. Before he was shot, Chaman was hacked by a machete.

According to the statement of claim, CGN employs security staff who previously served with military and paramilitary groups during the civil war.

No arrests have been made by Guatemalan authorities for either the rapes or murder of Chaman, according to the statements of claim.

"As lawyers and Canadian citizens it's quite heartbreaking to see the brutality of what is done abroad under the Canadian flag," Klippenstein said. "Right now Canadian companies seem to be operating without accountability. When those women were gang-raped by men wearing a Canadian subsidiary's logo on their uniform - that's just wrong. We're optimistic and determined because we have to be."

HMI Nickel is a wholey-owned subsidiary of HudBay Minerals. In 2007 it was an independent, Vancouver-based mining company called Skye Resources Inc.

HudBay Minerals bought out Skye Resources and converted it to the wholey-owned subsidiary, now known as HMI Nickel, on Aug. 26, 2008. Former Skye Minerals CEO Colin Brenner joined HudBay as a director and Skye Minerals CFO David Byson became a vice president and CFO of HudBay.

Through the Guatemalan company Compaia Guatemalteca de Niquel SA (CGN) -of which HMI Nickel owns 98.2 per cent and the Guatemalan government 1.8 per cent - HudBay Minerals holds a 25-year renewable exploitation license and exploration license to the Fenix Nickel Project.

Skye Minerals bought CGN in 2004, which was then known as EXMIBAL.

The Fenix Nickel Project includes 41.4 million tonnes of nickel reserves over a 248 sq. km area in eastern Guatemala near El Estor. The Fenix Nickel Project consists of an open-pit mine, processing plant, power plant and mineral rights to 248 sq. km of nickel deposits.

Canadian mining company Inco, now called Vale, started construction of the mine in 1965 and operated it from 1977 to 1980 when low nickel prices shut it down. At the time of the mine was in operation the Government of Guatemala owned 30 per cent of the project, that since has been negotiated down to 1.8 per cent.

According to the statement of claim, several Mayan Q'eqchi' communities resettled and began farming on areas of the defunct mine following the 1980s. The Mayan claim HudBay and its subsidiaries have no legal claim to the land, which was granted to Inco by the Guatemalan military dictatorship during the bloody Guatemalan Civil War.

During the civil war, which lasted from 1960 to 1996, Guatemala's indigenous populations were brutally oppressed, murdered and driven off their traditional lands. Archeological excavations of mass grave sites continue to try to piece together the remains of those "disappeared" during the civil war.

In 2006, the United Nations ruled that Guatemala had violated international law by granting the mining permit to Skye Resources without consulting the Maya Q'eqchi. However, according to the statement of claim, no action was taken by either the company or Guatemalan government.

In an e-mailed response, HudBay spokesman Daniel Weinerman said the company is undertaking an investigation into the claims made in the lawsuit.

"The allegations regarding the events of January,2007, while inconsistent with our understanding, have been made very recently and we are investigating them," Weinerman wrote. "Basedon reports available at the time from internal and government sources, we understand that a legal evictionwas conducted by the Guatemalan government, and that substantial effort was made to keep the evictions nonviolent. The allegations you have mentioned have only been recently brought to our attention, and we would never condone the types of actions that are alleged. Since we acquired an interest in the Fenix project in late 2008, HudBay has been committed to resolving the ongoing issue of illegal land occupations through peaceful and constructive dialogue, and HudBay has never been party to forced evictions."

Read Related Topics


NOTE: To post a comment you must have an account with at least one of the following services: Disqus, Facebook, Twitter, Google+ You may then login using your account credentials for that service. If you do not already have an account you may register a new profile with Disqus by first clicking the "Post as" button and then the link: "Don't have one? Register a new profile".

The Prince George Citizen welcomes your opinions and comments. We do not allow personal attacks, offensive language or unsubstantiated allegations. We reserve the right to edit comments for length, style, legality and taste and reproduce them in print, electronic or otherwise. Comments that contain external links will not be permitted. For further information, please contact the editor or publisher, or see our Terms and Conditions.

comments powered by Disqus

Unidentified Flying Object POLL

Do you believe in UFOs?

or  view results

Popular Citizen

Lowest Gas Prices in Prince George
Prince George Gas Prices provided by GasBuddy.com