The 2017 election is a good example of why proportional representation does not work. It appears we have a party with 16 per cent of the popular vote that is in control through balance-of-power - a rare occurrence with first past the post but a regular hindrance with proportional representation.
The Greens are happy of course, but European experience shows quite different single-issue parties can arise. It is the specter of these nationalist parties we ought to consider. A preferred ballot produces a more credible majority that reflects the voters' concerns more accurately. I know the referendum failed, because it required a super majority and both Liberals and NDP know they have achieved control with less than half the popular vote (for this reason the Greens should not just assume they will get proportional representation) and campaigned against it openly or otherwise.
Either way the time is ripe for this discussion, whether the politicians like it or not.
Brett Blaikie,
Prince George
