Search | Login | Letter to the Editor | Contact Us
Monday, October 13, 2008
Temp: 6°C
Feels like: 6°C
Humidity: 100%
INTEGRIS  
Find a CarFind a Car
Find a HouseFind a House
TV ListingsTV Listings
 
Mistrial declared
Oct 10, 15:30 (Hits: 538) -- Comments: (3)
 

My Account

SPRING SUMMER SALE

Gallery

 

HIV group furious after disease alert on plane Print E-mail
Written by SCOTT STANFIELD
Citizen staff
  
Tuesday, 08 April 2008
Several members of a local HIV/AIDS support agency are considering filing a human rights complaint after a security guard at the Prince George Airport ordered a plane to be wiped down after they got off.
The 10-person group that was flying via WestJet to a conference in Vancouver on March 28, was delayed about 40 minutes when the security guard raised concerns about "diseases," according to a Positive Living North employee.
The guard had allegedly recognized someone in the group and asked for a wipe down of the aircraft after the group left the plane.
"This situation presented itself by what appears to be an unfortunate choice of words by people that don't work for WestJet," said airline spokesman Richard Bartrem. "Essentially, it wasn't so much an issue as a non-issue, and it took us 40 minutes to make that determination. Ultimately, the captain said 'This is ridiculous, they're welcome guests on board our aircraft. Let's get going.'"
"Why did this happen? What disease was (the guard) talking about?" said PLN co-executive director Catherine Baylis. "I've worked with people with HIV for nine years, and I've not contracted HIV. That notion is ridiculous, but then again, HIV was never mentioned by the airport security staff.
"Some of the people who were on the plane are very upset. Most of those people are aboriginal people. I understand the oppression that goes with being aboriginal, and when you add to that the fact that you have a disease and you are marginalized, then you face all kinds of discrimination. Some of those people want to file a human rights complaint, some of them don't know they have the right to do that."
Tina Joyce, 30, who is living with AIDS, was among the group. She suggests the security guard made a judgment call before getting the facts straight.
"I was really disgusted," she said.
The Canada Air Transport Security Association contracts airport security to Garda of Canada.
"I would like an apology from (the guard) to our group," Baylis said.
Joe Gavaghan, a Boston-based spokesman for Garda World Security, said management became aware of the situation on Monday.
"We're looking into this to try to figure out exactly what did happen," Gavaghan said. "Once we're able to do that, then we'll be in a position to decide what actions need to be taken."
"It concerns us any time the customer service experience is affected," airport aviation services manager Todd Doherty said Tuesday. "We're doing an investigation and have asked for feedback from our service providers, which would be Garda and CATSA. It's between the two groups, and we'll facilitate whatever we can."
Baylis said she has received a call from a Garda representative, who suggested PLN provide education for airport security staff.
"We're going to do that," Baylis said. "Ultimately, we are about advocating for the rights of people with HIV, and we are about educating the community. And that's the only way we can reduce stigma and discrimination."

Comments (6)add
Aids survivors further stigmatized
written by jtosoff , April 09, 2008 (08:35:53 AM)
I am appalled at the security firm at the PG airport. I work for the Prince George sexual assault center( Recently changed to the PG SOS Society) as the Men`s trauma counsellor and have clients who live with this devastating diseaze and i am disgusted at this. With all the info out there on this subject in the media this is shocking and dissappointing to say the least. I truly hope Catherin of PLN goes all the way to filing a complaint with human rights. Maybe the security company should make a substantial donation to PLN for thier employees callous and insensitive actions and fire that person. Not that this would change thier company representatives demoralizing actions but at least it would show some compassion and remorse. They could if they were serious about rectifying this also make a public apology through PLN to each and every person who was misstreated by them.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: -1
Fire:
written by Pissed off Tax Payer , April 09, 2008 (08:44:23 AM)
I think they should fire the individual that caused this problem. I know more than one individual on staff who are discriminatory against whoever they feel like it. Its stupid that they are able to remain on staff. For instance, one person had hit their head on the ice outside in the airport parking lot. One guard was there helping and everything else. Later in the day, the gentleman and a travel companion were clearing security to travel and she stayed there interrogating him as to why he shouldn't travel, he's not fit enough, and he doesn't deserve to be on the plane. That is rude, being a b*tch, and being plain arrogant. That pisses me off how GARDA can get away with things like that. There are some who go out of their way to lend an helping hand, and there a couple who misstreat their position and people underneath them.


report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: -1
how is this discrimination?
written by krisb , April 09, 2008 (11:52:34 AM)
First off, how did the group even become aware of the fact that the security personnel asked for a wipe-down of the plane after they had been on it?

Second, how is this discrimination? It didn't mean they weren't allowed to board the plane, and it didn't mean they were detained or delayed.

I recognize that HIV is a blood-borne pathogen (not air-borne), however who's to know if someone suffered a minor cut, bloody nose or motion sickness, contaminating a surface?

Personally, I see airplanes as cesspools already -- you're putting 50 people into a confined space for an hour or more, circulating the same air throughout... anything they can do to perhaps reduce the disease transmission, ESPECIALLY for diseases that have no cure, is a welcome addition, and this guard should be APPLAUDED.

It's funny how in first aid classes, we teach the first thing to do is grab your barriers -- e.g. gloves and resuscitation mask -- yet, when it comes to daily life, we have a problem when a "wipe-down" is requested.

Seriously... cheers to Garda for having some on-the-ball security and safety measures, rather than the arbitrary and pointless ones we see at US airports!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +4
Ignorance is alive and well
written by RUEZ , April 09, 2008 (01:00:47 PM)
Aids/Hiv has been with us since the early 80's and I have yet to hear about someone contracting it from being in an airplane or a bus or similar enclosed transport. I thought the days of ignorance were over.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: -1
call it ignorance, but...
written by krisb , April 09, 2008 (01:18:12 PM)
The prevalence of HIV has certainly grown since the 80's, and I'm certain there are a few people out there that have no idea how they got it.

Furthermore, there have been reported cases of someone with bloody sputum coughing on another person has transmitted HIV or similar pathogens. Since the possibility is there, why take the risk?

A further argument can be made that since HIV is most prevalent among the drug and homosexual communities, as is Hepatitis, that an HIV infected person is more likely to be carrying other pathogens which could spread more easily than HIV, warranting an increase level of caution.

Bottom line: don't fault people for being over-cautious with things that have no recourse if they fail to act and were right. I shrug my shoulders at a lot of the airport security measures -- especially the US requirement of removing your footwear -- but this one actually makes sense.

-kb
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
...
written by edauntes15 , April 09, 2008 (03:42:22 PM)
I'd have to agree with the airport on this one, they did the right thing. It's just too risky otherwise.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
You must be logged in to a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy
Last Updated ( Wednesday, 08 October 2008 )
 
 
The Northern


Who's Online

We have 46 guests and 1 member online